Put-in-Bay, Put In Bay Island Hotel Resort Conference Center home Bookmark Us Put-in-Bay on Facebook Put-in-Bay on Twitter Put-in-Bay on Pinterest Put-in-Bay on YouTube Baybucks coupons Last Minute Lodging! home putinbay cottages put in bay weather putinbay lodging promotions event calendar contact us

Put in Bay Shopping

Mr. Ed's Gift Shop               Editor's Choice!Mr Eds
Mr. Ed's Gift Shop This gift shop features Mr. Ed's Bar and Grill apparel, including the famous "Nobody's ugly after 2" shirts, hats, and accessories. Located inside Mr. Ed's Bar, downtown Put-in-Bay.

Delaware Ave. || 419-285-5042 || Web Page

Airborne DesignsPut in Bay Shopping
Airborne Designs CLOSED!!! A collection of unique Put-in-Bay attire created on the Island. Located next to Put-in-Bay Brewing Company.

Catawba Ave. || 419-285-3333 ||  

Bay Designs JewelersPut in Bay Shopping
Bay Designs CLOSED!!! Specializes in Put-in-Bay prints and nautical gold jewelry. Located across from the town hall.

220 Delaware Ave. || 419-285-7625 ||  

Blue Cottage GalleryPut in Bay Shopping
Blue Cottage Gallery CLOSED!!! Visit Put-in-Bay's original art gallery, which features local and area artists who work in all mediums: oil, water color, jewelry, stained glass, ceramics, pottery, glass, metal, photography and more. Stop by every Saturday to meet the artists and watch them work, or attend a class and be an artist yourself. Blue Cottage Gallery also carries the CDs of the local entertainers. Located across from the visitor's center in Harbor Village.

185 Toledo Ave. || 419-285-2128 ||  

The Candy BarPut in Bay Shopping
The Candy Bar The Candy Bar is "the sweetest bar on the island." Located downtown at the end of Delaware Avenue, this sweet shop sells homemade fudge that's 1/4 lb. a slice, children's novelty candy, salt water taffy, and everything under the sun that can dipped in chocolate, including fresh fruit, pretzels and cookies. We have an ice cream shop that sells ice cream, shakes, sundaes, etc. The Candy Bar is definitely the island's guilty pleasure.

198 Delaware Ave. || 419-285-2920 || Web Page

The Cargo NetPut in Bay Shopping
The Cargo Net CLOSED!!! Specializing in restored marine antiques and nostalgia. Nautical items from mostly WWII and before. Rare items from the past for your decorating desires. Make this a "destination", not just a trip! We carry many "nostalgia" items also, such as slot machines, national cash registers, barber chairs and poles, as well as bronzes.

1961 Langram Rd. || 419-285-4231 || Web Page

The Carriage HousePut in Bay Shopping
The Carriage House This shop carries a wide selection of Put-in-Bay novelties, along with a small selection of jewelry, and children's gifts. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

160 Delaware Ave. || 419-285-2212 || Web Page

Cellar CachePut in Bay Shopping
Cellar Cache CLOSED!!! This shop specializes in distinctive glass collectibles and artwork. Located one block from downtown.

Catawba Ave. || 419-285-2738 ||  

The Country HousePut in Bay Shopping
The Country House This huge store has a wide variety of items with something for everyone, from kids to grandparents. For children, find toys, room and dorm decorations or something from the new baby section. Each week a featured table has merchandise matching the weekend's theme, such as Independence Day, Christmas in July, etc. Decorations and accessories come in Victorian, country and nautical (including pirates) designs. Check out the front porch for great deals on sale items.

246 Delaware Avenue || 419-285-4595 || Web Page

Crystal Cave Gift ShopPut in Bay Shopping
Crystal Cave Gift Shop This small gift shop offers a unique variety of crystal, geode, and other gems. Some pieces are from inside the cave. Located at Heineman's Winery.

978 Catawba Ave. || 419-285-2811 || Web Page

The Cuckoo's NestPut in Bay Shopping
The Cuckoo's Nest CLOSED!!! The Cuckoo's Nest carries a wide variety of tropical items with a Key West vibe. Find fun and colorful dinnerware for your boat or pool, purses, lady's wear and metal art. Flip flop-themed collectibles and metal palm trees are popular items. Bath and body items are also available in this Caribbean-feel shop. Shipping and boat delivery available.

Catawba Avenue || PHONE ||  

Island Surf ShopPut in Bay Shopping
Island Surf Shop Island Surf Shop. Providing Put-In-Bay with island style comfort and fashion you won't find anywhere else on the island. Unique gifts, original art, and hip apparel designed and created by us, the Original Island Surf Shop.

216 Toledo Avenue || 419-285-7873 || Web Page

Jessie's JewelryPut in Bay Shopping
Jessie's Jewelry Unique handmade, custom wire-wrapped jewelry is a family affair at Jessie's. Her father cuts the stones and her mother does wire crocheting. Jessie is an expert on gemstones and their properties and travels all over the world to pick out the most beautiful rocks. Each year she makes an island-inspired line - our favorite is a pendant/pin in the shape of the monument, made from a piece of stone that fell from it several years ago. Jessie also can shape wire around a stone in the shape of your boat. Don't miss the hand-painted scarves and purses from Bali as well.

160 Thompson Rd. || 330-608-4664 || Web Page

Lovella Fashion ApparelPut in Bay Shopping
Lovella Fashion Apparel Lovella Fashion Apparel keeps up to date on the hottest trends with the biggest men's and women's clothing selection in the area, featuring fashion from designers like Prada, Gucci, Dior, Armani and Dolce and Gabbana. Find bathing suits, sunglasses, dresses, casual clothes, accessories, shoes and more. T-shirts are available in sizes up to 6X. Check out the 3 for $10 sale, one of the best deals on the island.

259 Delaware Avenue || 419-285-5010 || Web Page

Looney BinPut in Bay Shopping
Looney Bin CLOSED!!! The Looney Bin is the perfect place to pick up fun entertainment items for your next cocktail party. This upscale store has unique drink novelty items for all ranges of budgets. Don't forget the wine -sold at state minimum. Choose from island favorites like wine from Lonz and Pelee Island, or try the tongue-in-cheek Mommy's Time Out or M譡ge a Tois. Check out the hand-painted wine glasses from Austria.

Catawba Avenue across from The Brewery ||   ||  

Mariners LockerPut in Bay Shopping
Mariners Locker Offers a wide variety of upscale clothing and accessories. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

204 Hartford Ave. || 419-285-6128 || Web Page

Misty Bay BoutiquePut in Bay Shopping
Misty Bay Boutique Carries a wide array of fine clothing and footwear. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

210 Delaware Ave. || 419-285-7925 || Web Page

More For KidsPut in Bay Shopping
More For Kids CLOSED!!! A store where clerks don costumes and kids are encouraged to try out the toys, More For Kids is truly a hands-on, child friendly place. The store has a reading corner, arts and crafts, puppet theater, magician kits, dress up and action playsets for kids to try out. Check out the daily story time to give the little ones time to unwind.

Catawba Avenue ||   ||  

Perry's Cave Shop On TopPut in Bay Shopping
Perry's Cave Shop On Top A shop full of Perry's Cave memorabilia and great souvenirs for the family. Located above Perry's Cave.

979 Catawba Ave. || 419-285-2405 || Web Page

Puddle Duck ShopPut in Bay Shopping
Puddle Duck Shop CLOSED!!! This shop offers upscale women's and children's apparel. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

Harbor Square || 419-285-2300 ||  

Put-in-Bay Surf ShopPut in Bay Shopping
Put-in-Bay Surf Shop Want to look hot while you're out at the Bay? Put-in-Bay Surf Shop has what you need. Find men's and women's bathing suits, shoes, board shorts, dresses, purses, jewelry and bags by favorite brands Quicksilver, Billabong, Roxy, Oakley, Rusty, Reef and more. Trendy, So Cal style that's perfect for island life.

389 Catawba Avenue || 419-285-2242 || Web Page

The Shirt ShackPut in Bay Shopping
The Shirt Shack The Shirt Shack has a wide variety of casual apparel for the entire family, from Put in Bay T-shirts to sweatshirts to bathing suits in all colors, styles and sizes. Besides baseball caps, visors and straw hats, the shack has a huge selection of wacky hats that kids and adults will get a kick out of. Everything else you need for island fun - leis, sunglasses, Put in Bay key chains, shot glasses and more - is for sale here.

Delaware Ave. || 419-285-4144 || Web Page

Silly GoosePut in Bay Shopping
Silly Goose CLOSED!!! At Silly Goose, you can find everything from darling infant clothes, including the trendy Robeez slipper shoes, to nostalgia games. Pick up the ever-popular Wind and Willow dessert and cheeseball mixes or the Wake Up Crabby Bloody Mary mix - some people even buy it by the case! Other favorite items include local artwork, candles, high-quality Put-in-Bay sweatshirts and handmade decorations from Africa. Shipping and boat delivery available.

Catawba Avenue ||   ||  

South Bass Bessie'sPut in Bay Shopping
South Bass Bessie's CLOSED!!! This upscale men's store with a nautical theme has everything a guy's island wardrobe could need: polos, T's, belts, shorts and sweatshirts. There is also clothing for toddlers from sizes 2T - 6. Fun food and spices available include Wake Up Crabby Bloody Mary mix, hot sauces, stuffed olives and gourmet pasta sauces. Shipping and boat delivery available.

Harbor Village || 419-285-6134 ||  

Stonehenge GiftsPut in Bay Shopping
Stonehenge Gifts Features unique gifts from the past, and Stonehenge memorabilia. Located at Stonehenge.

808 Langram Road || 419-285-6134 || Web Page

Through the GrapevinePut in Bay Shopping
Through the Grapevine CLOSED!!! A lovely collection of items for the home. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

Harbor Square || 419-285-2423 ||  

WharfsidePut in Bay Shopping
Wharfside Chances are that if you can't find it anywhere else on Put-in-Bay, you can get it at Wharfside. This shop on the water is the only place on Put in Bay with all the marine supplies you'd need, including fishing licenses and live bait. They also sell everything from pots and pans, to shampoo, to Put in Bay gifts. The friendly folks at Wharfside will also freeze your fish if you need them to. Coffee, breakfast sandwiches, bakery and cold drinks are available as well.

Bay View Avenue next to the Boardwalk || 419-285-4511 || Web Page

The Bucket ShopPut in Bay Shopping
The Bucket Shop A complete selection of Roundhouse gear and accessories. Located inside of the famous Roundhouse Bar, downtown Put-in-Bay.

Delaware Ave. || 419-285-7012 || Web Page

Wyland GalleryPut in Bay Shopping
Wyland Since 1978, Wyland Galleries has been the art community's preeminent showcase for the finest in marine life paintings, sculpture and photography. In the spirit of artist Wyland's original vision, Wyland Galleries continues to provide the highest quality fine art, and is considered one of the world's premiere fine art galleries, inspiring art lovers and collectors from over seventy countries. Located downtown Put-in-Bay.

495 Catawba Ave. || 419-285-2233 || Web Page