Resturaunt Reviews

baylink · Post by **baylink** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 9:53 am

After making my 5th trip to the Bay this past weekend I decided to do a review of the resturants that I ate at this year.
Ratings: **** Excellant
*** Good
** Fair
* Poor

Boardwalk **** This is a must if you go to the Bay, I know I always do. Best Seafood on the island and the Bisque is an obsolute must on every visit. Eat it on the top deck (Skybar) for the best view while dining on the island.

Boathouse **** Never had a bad meal there and the walleye is the best on the island.

Skyway *** Although I only ate there once this year, do to the location outside of town, my dinner as usual was very good and I look forward to going back.

Mossbacks *** Always enjoy eating there and they have a wide variety of selections, all of which are good.

Mr Eds *** I should really try something else but the perch basket with the fresh cut fries are what I have every time. Although I did have a deli sandwich at the coffee shop and it was also very goood.

Irving's Deli *** One of the best deli's you will every eat at and they deliver late nights on the weekend

Tippers *** Alot of people would argue with me but I always seem to get a good meal at a fair price. The steak specials during the week are especially good.

Chicken Patio *** If you like BBQ chicken you'll love this place, Another of my late night favorites.

Frostys *** This review is for breakfast only. It's the best on the island.

Hot dog stand accross from the Brewery *** Great for a quick bite to eat.

Joe's *** Sloppie Scottie says it all

Crescent * Food Fair, portions small, price high.

Last review is for pizza:
Cameo ***
Brewery ***
Beer Barrell ***
Frostys **

These are all the places I ate at this year so next year I'll try some of the others.

Mills · Post by **Mills** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 12:00 pm

I have to agree for the most part except if your review is for breakfast at Cresent Tavern it gets ZERO stars from me!!! It is the absolute worst food I have ever eaten

mobay · Post by **mobay** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 12:54 pm

I have to disagree on the Pizza review. The brewery imo is hands down the best on the island, and frosty should be 1 star for those cheese covered frisbees they pawn off as pizzas.

Mills · Post by **Mills** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 2:32 pm

1) Brewery
2) Cameo's
3) Frosty's

I totally agree Frosty's is way overrated!!! And my friends are the biggest culprits behind this, they insist on eating dinner there every single night which is crazy!!

Mister Kay · Post by **Mister Kay** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 2:39 pm

I like the Boathouse or eating corndogs all day at the Dairy Queen.

The chix casedella (sp?) wraps were real good at the PIB Resort Tiki Bar.

candita4 · Post by **candita4** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 3:11 pm

Frosty's makes the worst pizza in the world. Think cardboard with cheese on top. I think it's on purpose so when you eat that stuff drunk, you can't tell the pizza from the carton.

CabinGirl · Post by **CabinGirl** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 3:23 pm

haa, I like your spelling Kay! Quesadillas

are probably my fav food right now. I'll have to check them out at the Tiki.

Oh - just wanted to point out that the chicken is wine basted and not BBQ. That whole meal is the greatest!

I agree that the bisque in a bread bowl is a must when visiting the Bay, best pizza is Brewery, and the pizza at Frosty's is pizza box with cheese

Mister Kay · Post by **Mister Kay** » Tue Sep 06, 2005 3:54 pm

Actually, yes the WINE BASTED chicken dinner at the Chicken Patio is the best meal.

The lobster bisque is also quite good.

Bullette · Post by **Bullette** » Wed Sep 28, 2005 12:38 pm

I have to agree on the CAmeo pizza and the pizza from the Beer Barrel... I haven't had them this past year, but the year before they were phenomenal...

WCM · Post by **WCM** » Mon Jan 29, 2007 2:53 pm

ooh...the Chicken Pit chicken...hands down the best food item on the Island, IMO. Followed by the bisque at The Boardwalk.

And if you ever happen to be there during the week of the Tarpon Springs Shrimp special at The Boardwalk, that's great too.

I'm usually pretty drunk when I eat pizza there, so its hard to say...

funboy2121 · Post by **funboy2121** » Mon Jan 29, 2007 4:42 pm

Only 16 more posts WCM!

WCM · Post by **WCM** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 10:07 am

I think I should celebrate!

Simple_man5 · Post by **Simple_man5** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 11:43 am

Who goes there to eat? It takes up room meant for alcohol. :lol:

kindy52 · Post by **kindy52** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 12:25 pm

I like the Roundhouse Chicken and the Gazebo Briskett!

Bullette · Post by **Bullette** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 12:47 pm

11 more posts are you are golden!

Putinbay.com

Resturaunt Reviews

PIB Food

xxx