For 8 guys for a bachelor party I would definitely say get 2 hotel rooms in the old section of The Commodore! That way you are right in the middle of everything within crawling distance of your bed LOL!! The old section is cheaper and has a balcony that overlooks the new Mist swim up bar which would be cool!!
My 2nd reccommendation would be the Edgewater above Mama Maria's pizza/subs. Good location although I have never stayed there and cant say what the rooms are like. They look nice!
Mills, from Cincinnati
If life is a waste of time, and time is a waste of life, then let's all get wasted together and have the time of our lives!!!!